Quantcast
Channel: Nathan A. Finn » Books
Viewing all 36 articles
Browse latest View live

Francis Wayland and Richard Fuller: Debating Slavery with Christian Civility

$
0
0

My latest post for the Andrew Fuller Center for Baptist Studies is titled “Francis Wayland and Richard Fuller: Debating Slavery with Christian Civility.” The post speaks to the famous Wayland-Fuller epistolary debate over slavery, which was published in the 1845 book Domestic Slavery Considered as a Scriptural Institution. My colleague Keith Harper and I co-edited a new edition of Domestic Slavery for Mercer University Press in 2008.

Here’s my concluding paragraph from the post:

Their respective arguments notwithstanding, Domestic Slavery is a model of Christian civility. Wayland and Fuller continually refer to each other as “my dear friend,” and in this case, they really meant it. Neither engages in ad hominem attacks of the other. Both men are quick to affirm anything they see as right and truthful in the other’s argument. Though Wayland really does believe Fuller is misreading Scripture, and though Fuller really is convinced Wayland is ignoring Scripture, the two men are always cordial and dignified; they never paint the other as sub-Christian or impugn each other’s motives. These two esteemed antebellum Baptists remind us that it is possible to debate even the most controversial issues in a Christ-like manner.

You can go to the Fuller Center’s website to read the whole essay.

 


Book Recommendation: The Little Way of Ruthie Lemming

$
0
0

I recently read Rod Dreher’s new book The Little Way of Ruthie Leming: A Southern Girl, a Small Town, and the Secret of a Good Life (Grand Central, 2013). If you aren’t familiar with him, Dreher is a former journalist and the author of the insightful book Crunchy Cons: The New Conservative Counterculture and Its Return to Roots. He’s also blogs regularly at The American Conservative’s website.

The Little Way of Ruthie Lemming is a delightful memoir that really tells three overlapping stories at the same time. First, it is the story of Dreher’s sister Ruthie Lemming, a wife, mother, and public school teacher who passed away from an aggressive form of cancer in 2011. Ruthie positively influenced many people, even though she lived all of her life except for her college years in her rural Louisiana hometown. Second, it is the story of Dreher’s complicated relationship with Ruthie, his parents, and the hometown he left behind shortly after finishing college. In the wake of Ruthie’s death, Dreher and his family moved back to the very place he had escaped from two decades earlier. Finally, it is the story of the residents of St. Francisville, Louisiana and surrounding communities. By the end of the book, you feel like you know many of them.

I connected with this book on many levels. Like Dreher, I’m a small-town boy who received more education and embraced more cosmopolitan interests than many of the folks around whom I grew up. Like Dreher, when I was in my twenties I turned my nose up a bit at my South Georgia heritage (though I mostly kept my opinions to myself). Like Dreher my religious convictions aren’t always in sync with my upbringing (he is a Methodist convert to Eastern Orthodoxy by way of Roman Catholicism, while I’m more theologically oriented and ecumenically minded than many of my fellow Southern Baptists back home). Like Dreher, the older I’ve gotten the more I’ve become a traditionalist conservative (as opposed to the Fox News kind of conservative) who appreciates the blessing of kinship and friendship, the wisdom found in tradition, the importance of roots, and strategic importance of mediating institutions such as schools, civic clubs, and, of course, congregations.

In our world of chain restaurants, franchise churches, cookie-cutter suburban neighborhoods, Big Government, and Big Business, I increasingly find the simpler path–the little way–to be very appealing. That said, I confess I’m not going to move back to my hometown, in part because (unlike Dreher) my job as a professor doesn’t allow me to work from anywhere with a wireless internet connection. Nevertheless, The Little Way of Ruthie Lemming has helped me to further appreciate my own roots in the small town Deep South. My wife and I are constantly trying to figure out ways to best embody the sort of vision Dreher advocates in our own suburban context in the quintessentially New South metropolitan area of Raleigh-Durham, North Carolina.

Anyway, I would highly recommend you read The Little Way of Ruthie Leming. If you do give it a look, let me know if you resonate with it the same way I do.

On “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God”

$
0
0

If you know much of anything about Jonathan Edwards’s preaching, you know that his most famous sermon is “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God.” The sermon is available in numerous stand-alone print editions, is reprinted in most anthologies of Edwards’s works, and is widely available in audio form on the internet.

Pastor and Edwards scholar Josh Moody discusses “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God” in his FAQ section on the Jonathan Edwards Center website:

1. Is “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God” representative of Edwards’ entire ministry?

  • “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God” was preached at a church that was reportedly resistant to the work of the Great Awakening, the massive transatlantic revival taking place at the time. Edwards preached many other sermons in other contexts (for instance, famously, his series on Charity and Its Fruits), but it is fair to say that Edwards believed strongly not only in the fearful reality of hell but his duty as a minister to warn people of that reality.
  • Having said that, to call, as some have, Edwards’ hell-fire preaching effectively ‘theological terrorism’ is quite unjustified. Even the sermon itself Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God has, when read properly, a clear emphasis upon the mercy of God – it is nothing but God’s mercy that keeps us out of hell, he was saying, and therefore we are to ask God for an extension of that mercy for salvation.
  • So is Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God representative? Yes, Edwards did preach on hell, and did seek to warn people of hell most passionately and with vibrant and alarming imagery. But Edwards also preached on many other topics more frequently (love, the beauty of Christ), and preached this sermon in a particular context of what he discerned as hard-hearted resistance to the wonderful work of God. Perhaps Edwards’ preaching on hell stands out to us mostly (if not only) because we are so unaccustomed to finding warnings against hell in church or society today.

Far and away, the most helpful resource is Jonathan Edwards’s “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God” A Casebook (Yale University Press, 2010), edited by Wilson Kimnach, Caleb Maskell, and Kenneth Minkema. Check out the following blurb from the publisher.

Designed specifically for the classroom, this volume presents the accurate and definitive version of Sinners, accompanied by the tools necessary to study and teach this famous American sermon. With an introduction aimed at students and teachers and commentary that draws on fifty years of team editorial experience of Yale’s orks of Jonathan Edwards, it provides both context and interpretation, and addresses the concerns and questions of a twenty-first century audience.

The book contains questions for in-class discussion, a chronology of Edwards’s life, and a glossary. In addition, curricular materials and video mini-presentations are available on a dedicated Web site. This casebook represents a innovative contribution to the art of teaching Edwards to a new generation of readers.

The Jonathan Edwards Center at TEDS

$
0
0

Several times this week, I’ve mentioned The Jonathan Edwards Center at Yale University. The JEC website is the best place on the internet to begin a study of Edwards’s life and thought. Though the JEC provides numerous helpful resources, by far the most important of which is the free electronic edition of the 26-volume Works of Jonathan Edwards (plus another 47 volumes that are only available online).

Doug Sweeney

What many folks do not know is that several other institutions have launched Jonathan Edwards Centers that are connected to the JEC at Yale. In North America, the other “official” Jonathan Edwards Center is at Trinity Evangelical Divinity School, where it is under the direction of Doug Sweeney, a TEDS church historian. Sweeney is the author or editor of numerous scholarly and popular books related to Edwards and the New Divinity. The latter was an influential theological movement among second-generation Edwardseans. He is also the editor of volume 23 on Edwards’s “Miscellanies” in The Works of Jonathan Edwards.

I love the JEC-TEDS website. Sweeney and his team provide numerous audio lectures related to Edwards and the Edwardsean tradition. Lecturers include both top-shelf historians and theologians such as Mark Noll and Oliver Crisp (among many others) as well as influential pastors such as John Piper and Thabiti Anyabwile. The website also includes a helpful blog. Most of the posts are “book notes” by Sweeney that discuss recent works devoted to Edwards and related themes. I often look to see what Sweeney has said about a book before I start reading it myself. (He’s always read the book before I have.)

If you are interested in Jonathan Edwards, the second website you need to check out is The Jonathan Edwards Center at Trinity Evangelical Divinity School.

 

Don’t Judge a Theologian by His Unpublished Musings

$
0
0

(Note: A couple of weeks ago, I published the following post at Historia Ecclesiastica, the blog of the Andrew Fuller Center for Baptist Studies at Southern Seminary. I haven’t previously published it here at Christian Thought & Tradition.)

A good reminder from pastor and Jonathan Edwards scholar Josh Moody:

This brings up a more general point about Edwards’s many notebooks and “Miscellanies” from which Edwards scholars love to quote. They are fascinating, there are many of them, and they are rich with insights into how Edwards’s mind worked. But they can also be dangerous. We must never forget that they were not intended to be published. That they have been is a good thing because they give us insight into the working mind of an undisputed theological genius. But they are not necessarily fully-formed opinions. It’s like looking at Van Gogh’s oil paint palate and drawing conclusions about what kind of painting style he believed in. It might give us insight into his method, and we might draw some connections between that and what he painted, but it wouldn’t tell us finally what he wanted to paint. Only Edwards’s published works, by his own intention, during his own lifetime, reveal with certainty what he wanted to say. Perhaps Edwards has hidden opinions in his notebooks not consistent with his preaching and writing, but the majority of Edwards scholarship has long shown that not to be the case. Each time  I engage with fellow Edwards scholars on the “Miscellanies,” I make a fresh resolution to comb through all my personal extended notes and jottings on theological matters. If I am to be held to the stake for every semiformulated idea I have ever penned in private journals, I had better get rid of some of them before I pass through the veil.

See Moody’s helpful (and punchy) chapter “Edwards and Justification Today” in Jonathan Edwards and Justification (Crossway, 2012), ed. Josh Moody, pp. 30–31.

 

Book Announcement: The Community of Jesus

$
0
0

In September, our friends at B&H Academic are publishing a book titled The Community of Jesus: A Theology of the Church, edited by Kendall Easley and Christopher Morgan. My SEBTS colleagues Andreas Köstenberger and Bruce Ashford are among the contributors. You can read what the publisher has to say about the book below.

Intended for upper division college students, seminarians, and pastors, The Community of Jesus delivers a biblical, historic, systematic, and missional theology of the church.Today the word church provokes wide-ranging reactions and generates discussion on a variety of issues among Christians and non-Christians alike. In order to sort through this maze of responses and topics, a biblical and theological foundation must be laid that provides a clear vision of the church of the Lord Jesus Christ and its significance in God’s eternal purpose.

With extensive pastoral, teaching, missions, and administrative experience, this team of contributors carefully sets forth the biblical teachings concerning the church and then builds on this core material, relating the theology of the church to salvation history, church history, God’s glory, and God’s mission:

  • Paul R. House, “God Walks with His People: Old Testament Foundations”
  • Andreas J. Köstenberger, “The Church According to the Gospels”
  • Kendell H. Easley, “The Church in Acts and Revelation: New Testament Bookends”
  • David S. Dockery, “The Church in the Pauline Epistles”
  • Ray Van Neste, “The Church in the General Epistles”
  • James A. Patterson, “The Church in History: Ecclesiastical Ideals and Institutional Realities”
  • Stephen J. Wellum, “Beyond Mere Ecclesiology: The Church as God’s New Covenant Community”
  • Christopher W. Morgan, “The Church and the Glory of God”
  • Bruce Riley Ashford, “The Church in the Mission of God”

The B&H Academic Blog has recently published two posts by co-editor Chris Morgan anticipating the book: “I Loved the Church but Hated Ecclesiology” and “The Church as A Showcase of God’s Plan for Cosmic Unity (Part I).” More posts are forthcoming in the next few days.

I’m really excited about The Community of JesusIf you haven’t been paying attention, you ought to know that B&H Academic has regularly published some very helpful material in recent years on the topic of ecclesiology, including Mark Dever’s introductory text The Church: The Gospel Made Visible (2012), which I reviewed for The Gospel Coalition, and the edited volumes Believer’s Baptism: Sign of the New Covenant in Christ (2007),  Upon This Rock: A Baptist Understanding of the Church (2010), The Lord’s Supper: Remembering and Proclaiming Christ Until He Comes (2011), and Those Who Must Give an Account: A Study of Church Membership and Church Discipline (2012). Several current and former Southeastern faculty members and adjunct professors have contributed to one or more of these volumes, including Danny Akin, Bruce Ashford, Andy Davis, Nathan Finn, John Hammett, David Hogg, Köstenberger, Steve McKinion, and Ben Merkle.

(Note: This post was also published yesterday at Between the Times)

Reading the Christian Spiritual Classics: A Guide for Evangelicals

$
0
0

Reading Christian Spiritual ClassicsA few months back, I had the privilege of reading an excellent new book edited by Kyle Strobel and Jamin Goggin titled Reading the Christian Spiritual Classics: A Guide for Evangelicals (IVP Academic, 2013). The book is a collection of essays that serves to introduce evangelical readers to the discipline of reading spiritual classics. The book is wise, winsome and edifying. I would highly recommend it.

Today, The Gospel Coalition has published my review of the book. Here is my concluding paragraph:

Reading the Spiritual Classics is a great place to start for evangelicals who are trying to understand “the lay of the land” when it comes to Christian spirituality. But the editors and contributors will surely agree that reading this book is meant to be a gateway into the wonderful world of reading the spiritual classics themselves. Read this book, then take up and read a classic work of Christian spirituality. The editors include a helpful list of suggested readings in the back.

I hope you will check out the review and then read the book.

The Pure Flame of Devotion: The History of Christian Spirituality

$
0
0

The Pure Flame of DevotionLast week, I attended the annual meeting of the Evangelical Theological Society. While there, I was part of a dinner where a group of scholars, students, and pastors honored my friend Michael Haykin with a festschrift titled The Pure Flame of Devotion: The History of Christian Spirituality (Joshua Press, 2013). Michael is a widely regarded historian who has written widely in Patristic historical theology, Baptist history, Puritan history, and spirituality. I haven’t yet figured out how one dude can write on all those topics. Michael is a Canadian mystery wrapped in a Baptist enigma.

The Pure Flame of Devotion, edited by Steve Weaver and Ian Clary, is framed as a historical theological introduction to Christian spirituality. My own chapter is titled “Andrew Fuller’s Edwardsean Spirituality.” If you are interested in the history of Christian spirituality, I would encourage you to pick up a copy of The Pure Flame of Devotion.

From the Joshua Press website:

EDITED AND INTRODUCED BY

G. Stephen Weaver Jr. and Ian Hugh Clary

CONTRIBUTORS

Douglas Adams, Peter Beck, Joel R. Beeke, Nathan A. Finn, Keith Goad, Crawford Gribben, Francis X. Gumerlock, David S. Hogg, Erroll Hulse, Clint Humfrey, Sharon James, Mark Jones, Sean Michael Lucas, Tom J. Nettles, Dennis Ngien, Robert W. Oliver, Kenneth J. Stewart, Carl R. Trueman, Austin R. Walker, Donald S. Whitney, Malcolm B. Yarnell, Fred G. Zaspel.

Since the time of Christ, the church has known men and women renowned for their devotion, spiritual insight and piety. Collectively their lives portray a broad history of Christian spirituality. This volume is meant to ignite your interest and understanding of key time periods and pivotal people from various eras of church history. Instead of exploring the overall spiritual perspective of a person or period, only certain aspects of thought are dealt with. This is an approach to church history with an eye to issues of spirituality that emphasizes how today’s Christians can cull ancient sources for their spiritual enrichment and encouragement as they seek to live their lives under the direction of the Holy Spirit.

Each of the exceptional contributors is knowledgeable in their particular subject area.Through extensive original research they skillfully expound the vitality and richness of the spirituality of their subjects. Introduced to these historical figures who walked closely with God, Christians will find rich application and benefit for their souls. May this book stir up many more men and women to pursue intimate communion and fellowship with God, turning from all that distracts and devoting heart and soul to loving God and living for his glory and the spread of the kingdom of Jesus Christ.

 

 


On Evangelicals and Race: Two Recommendations

$
0
0

In my latest post at Between the Times, I recommend two books to help caucasian evangelicals in America better understand the present realities and future possibilities of a multiethnic evangelicalism. I hope you find these resources as helpful as I have.

Windows on the World: Praying the Great Commission

An Infinite Journey: Growing Toward Christlikeness

$
0
0

An Infinite JourneyI have the honor of serving as one of the elders of the First Baptist Church of Durham, North Carolina. In the eight years that my wife Leah and I have been members of the congregation, I have been blessed to become close friends with our church’s senior pastor, Andy Davis. For as long as I have known Andy, he has been writing a book on the topic of spiritual maturity. By God’s grace, that book has now been published. Lord willing, it will be the first of several books Andy will write (he is currently working on a commentary on Isaiah for B&H’s Christ-Centered Expositional Commentary series).

An Infinite Journey: Growing Toward Christlikeness (Ambassador International, 2014) is currently for sale at FBC Durham, was available to attendees of last week’s Cross Conference, and can be pre-ordered at Amazon, where it will be available January 10, 2014. In the book, Andy summarizes the Christian life as two infinite journeys: the internal journal of personal sanctification and the external journey of gospel proclamation. We emphasize the “two journey’s” theme repeatedly at FBC Durham. I’m grateful that this theme will reach a wider audience through An Infinite Journey.

I had the privilege of writing the foreword to An Infinite Journey, which I have included below. I hope you will buy the book and read it. If you do, I believe you will find it to be a helpful resource in your own spiritual journey.

During my teenage years, I became steeped in evangelical revivalism. I often got the impression from pastors and evangelists that salvation more or less equaled justification. From time to time, we learned about sanctification and glorification, but these truths were often assumed more than they were expounded. The real action was in getting saved, which meant being justified by faith in Jesus Christ as one’s personal Lord and Savior.

I spent several years trying to nail down the exact moment I had been justified, since I was taught that my assurance of salvation is based almost entirely upon my decision to believe in Jesus for salvation. I often worried that I had not been sincere enough in my faith because I still struggled with indwelling sin. I prayed some version or other of the “sinner’s prayer” dozens of time in an effort to be sure I was really saved. As far as I knew, the Christian life was about getting justified, knowing you were justified, and helping other people get justified.

I was in college when it first dawned upon me that salvation is not a single moment in time, but rather is a spiritual journey. Justification is not an end unto itself—it is the beginning of a spiritual pilgrimage that begins in this life and ultimately ends in the next life. I had been saved by grace through faith (justification), I was being saved as the Holy Spirit conformed me more to the image of my Savior (sanctification), and I would be saved at the last day when I am finally and forever freed from sin, sickness, sorrow, and suffering (glorification). It was liberating to finally understand that “he who began a good work in you will bring it to completion at the day of Jesus Christ” (Phil. 1:6, ESV).

Providentially, my wife and I became a part of the First Baptist Church of Durham, North Carolina in 2005. We had learned of Andy Davis and his ministry at the church from some mutual friends. We wanted a church that emphasizes expositional preaching, God’s sovereignty in salvation, meaningful church membership, and the importance of evangelism and missions; we found it at FBC Durham. Once we joined the church, we discovered that Andy often speaks of the Christian life as two infinite, interrelated journeys. In the past eight years, my own spirituality has been shaped by the awareness that I am on an inward journey toward sanctification and ultimately glorification and an outward journey to proclaim the lordship of Jesus Christ here, there, and everywhere.

An Infinite Journey is the fruit of many years of preaching and teaching on the nature of the Christian life, primarily in the context of a local church. I have watched Andy Davis faithfully model the two infinite journeys for the people he shepherds. I have seen this vision of the Christian life shape the spirituality of public school teachers, medical doctors, lawyers, businessmen, stay-at-home mothers, retirees, converted convicts, international graduate students, seminary students and professors, and foreign missionaries. I have become convinced that speaking of two infinite journeys is simply a helpful and memorable way to describe authentic, biblical Christianity.

I am glad you have decided to read this book; I do not believe you have done so by accident. My prayer is that An Infinite Journey will be a means of sanctifying grace in your own spiritual walk as you continue on the two infinite journeys of the Christian life.

 

The Complete Works of Andrew Fuller: Logos Edition

$
0
0

As regular readers of this blog probably know, I am very interested in the life and thought of Andrew Fuller (1754–1815), the famous English Baptist pastor-theologian. If you aren’t familiar with him, you can read the short blog post about him that I wrote for Desiring God several months ago. I am part of an international team of scholars who are collaborating on a new critical edition of Fuller’s Works that will be published by Walter de Gruyter beginning later this year. In 1988, Sprinkle Press published the best edition of Fuller’s corpus that is currently available. The “Sprinkle Edition,” which is comprised of three volumes, is a reprint of an 1845 edition of Fuller’s writings. Unfortunately, the Sprinkle Edition retails for about $100 and is double columned, making it both expensive and difficult to read.

LogosBibleSoftwareI was delighted to learn recently that Logos publishes an electronic version of The Complete Works of Andrew Fuller. The Logos Edition sells for $59.95. The Logos Edition includes the entirety of the Sprinkle Edition, including Tom Nettles’s brief introduction at the beginning of volume 1. Of course, it also provides all the benefits of the Logos platform as well. I am grateful to the folks at Logos for providing me with a review copy of The Complete Works of Andrew Fuller.

I have enjoyed working with the Logos Edition in recent days. I appreciate that it shows the page numbers of the Sprinkle Edition, which is helpful for citation purposes and is an advantage over other available electronic editions of Fuller’s writings, which do not include any sort of pagination. I also like how Logos allows for a single column format, which makes for much easier reading. This is especially helpful when I read on the Logos app on my iPad. It is comparable to reading a work on my Kindle or iBooks apps. The note-taking feature of Logos is very useful, especially for folks like me who are interested in both edifying reading and scholarly research.

Of course, if you are familiar with Logos, you know that hands-down the search function is the biggest plus about the Logos Edition of Fuller’s Works. The Sprinkle Edition has a serviceable index, but it pales in comparison to electronic word search capability. For example, I am currently working on a critical edition of Fuller’s 1810 book Strictures on Sandemanianism. My edition will include a lengthy introductory essay of 20,000 to 25,000 words. Being able to search for all the references to “Sandemanianism” and other key phrases in Fuller’s Works is an invaluable tool for me as I work on that essay.

Screen Shot 2014-01-02 at 4.18.19 PM

If you are a Logos user and you are interested in Andrew Fuller, Baptist historical theology, or the history of missions, British evangelicalism or Calvinist theology, I would highly recommend you pick up a copy of the Logos Edition of The Complete Works of Andrew Fuller. I would recommend you begin your reading of Fuller with his groundbreaking The Gospel Worthy of All Acceptation (2nd ed. 1801), which is available in volume II. This defense of evangelistic preaching from an Edwardsean Calvinist perspective is Fuller’s most influential work. Another good entry point is some of Fuller’s sermons, which are available in volume I. Start with “The Nature and Importance of Walking by Faith,” “Soul Prosperity” or his many ordination sermons (these typically have the words “minister” or “ministry” in the title). Still another place to begin is with Fuller’s circular letters written for the Northamptonshire Association, which are found in volume III. I would recommend “Causes of Declension in Religion, and Means of Revival,” “The Practical Uses of Christian Baptism” and “The Promise of the Spirit the Grand Encouragement in Promoting the Gospel.”

Those of you who are interested in systematic theology should take a look at his “Letters on Systematic Divinity” in volume I, wherein Fuller begins sketching out a crucicentric theological method. Unfortunately, he died just a few letters into his work. His shorter writings on imputation, justification, substitution and particular redemption in volume II provide a constructive (and sometimes controversial) understanding of salvation from an Edwardsean perspective. His Memoirs of the Rev. Samuel Pearce, found in volume III, is a warmhearted introduction to Fuller’s friend and fellow missions advocate. Pearce has been called “the Baptist Brainerd.” Pastors especially will appreciate Fuller’s homiletical commentaries on Genesis and Revelation, also found in volume III.

I’m grateful that Logos has made Fuller’s writings available on their platform. I hope the Logos Edition helps familiarize many modern pastors and scholars with the life and writings of the most famous heir of Jonathan Edwards among the Baptists. If you are not currently a Logos user, I would highly recommend the product to you. I have been using Logos for about three months and have found it to be a fantastic tool research, sermon preparation and general reading. You can find out which Logos package best fits your needs at the Logos website.

Michael Bird’s Evangelical Theology: Review and Response

$
0
0

Evangelical TheologyI have a confession: I love reading book reviews. When I open a new issue of a scholarly journal, normally the first thing I do is check out the reviews. When I read serious Christian periodicals such as First Things or Renewing Minds or The City, the reviews are often my favorite parts. I am a fan of Books and Culture, which is a semi-scholarly periodical consisting of virtually nothing but book review essays. I have served as a book review editor for two scholarly journals, The Journal of Baptist Studies (2007-2012) and Themelios (2010-present), in part because it allows me to pair up good reviewers with worthwhile books. I also enjoy writing book reviews and review essays for scholarly journals, serious Christian periodicals and even blogs.

One of the problems with book reviews is that authors rarely have the chance to respond to critical comments. And when they do respond, many authors are, well, petty. (Of course, many reviewers are also petty.) However, from time to time we have the chance to see some good dialogue related to a book. This is the case the past two days with Matthew Barrett’s review of Michael Bird’s recent book Evangelical Theology and Bird’s response to Barrett’s review. Barrett, who reviewed Bird’s book for The Gospel Coalition, has a couple of nice things to say about Bird’s general approach before offering a barrage of criticism, mostly related to Bird’s method and soteriology. When I read the review, I thought to myself that Barrett had offered a pretty severe review (obligatory pleasantries aside) of a book written by a significant scholar with a popular blog and a wicked sharp wit. The possibilities for carnage seemed to abound.

However, instead of complaining about Barrett’s review, Bird thoughtfully engages most of Barrett’s criticisms. That is not to say that Bird concedes any of Barrett’s points; he does not. Barrett and Bird define what it means to be “Reformed” differently, which is a not uncommon occurrence among scholars in different fields (biblical studies and systematic theology) who are writing for the interwebs. I have no doubt that many folks will agree with Barrett: Bird is not really Reformed (by which they mean orthodox). I also have no doubt that many folks will resonate with Bird: much of what passes for Reformed theology is more about a system than it is sound exegesis (eeeeevil neo-scholasticism). I’m not so much concerned with the debate itself as I am pleased to see this sort of interaction between scholars around a book review.

Barrett is a pretty epic book reviewer who is serious about defending his understanding of Calvinism, and Bird is a prolific blogger who seems to enjoy being a bit contrarian, so the cards were right, as it were, for this sort of interaction to occur online over Evangelical Theology. However, I hope that the internet provides us with opportunities to see other scholars in other fields interact similarly over other issues (anything–anything besides Reformed theology). The internet was made for this sort of thing.

In the interest of full disclosure, I should note that I own Evangelical Theology, but have not read it yet. Thus, I don’t have an opinion either way about Bird’s book, since I haven’t looked at it myself. I’m just a guy who loves book reviews and have enjoyed watching this discussion transpire over the past couple of days.

How Scripture Functions When We Meditate on its Words

$
0
0

Meditation and CommunionI am currently reading John Jefferson Davis’s recent book Meditation and Communion with God: Contemplating Scripture in an Age of Distraction. It is a creative combination of systematic theology, epistemology, psychology and spirituality.  In a chapter on how to read the Bible for meditation, Davis speaks to how Scripture functions when we meditate on its words.

We can recognize at least four functions or purposes of Scripture in the community of faith: the informative, the transformative, the imaginative and the unitive. The first two are widely recognized and not problematic; the latter two are not self-evident and require a bit of justification….

I would argue that believing meditation on the Scriptures, when illuminated by the Holy Spirit, can function in all four dimensions: informative, transformative, imaginative and unitive. By imaginative I mean the function of Scripture in opening up our minds to the reality of the unseen, heavenly age to come that is already arriving—a countercultural biblical consciousness (Rom 12:1–2) that gives us the cognitive resources to push back against the accommodating forces of worldliness. By unitive I mean the function of Scripture, by virtue of our union with Christ and the illuminating action of the Holy Spirit, to bring us into an awareness and actual experience of the enjoyable presence of Christ (cf. “I say these things … so that they may have the full measure of my joy within them [Jn 17:13]).

Especially for those of us who may be seminarians, pastors or other religious professionals, it is good to be reminded of the fact that Scripture was given not only for the purpose of providing information and instruction for ourselves and others—sermon outline and Bible studies—but also, and more finally, for bringing us into the enjoyment of communion with the Lord who loves us, and who is really present to us through the Scriptures.

From John Jefferson Davis, Meditation and Communion with God: Contemplating Scripture in an Age of Distraction (IVP Academic, 2013), pp. 105–106.

 

 

How To Stay Christian in Seminary

$
0
0

How To Stay Christian in SeminarySatan is alive and well. One of the ways the enemy wreaks havoc in seminaries and Christian colleges is by causing young men and women to grow personally numb to the spiritual truths they are studying in their classes. We’ve all met seminary graduates who felt like they had to recover something that had become stagnant in their spiritual walk during their time in school. While I believe the prevalence of these stories is sometimes exaggerated–I know far, FAR more students whose spiritual walks have blossomed in seminary–there is no doubt that many seminarians have left school with hearts that have grown cold toward the Lord, his church and the lost.

I am very grateful that David Mathis and Jonathan Parnell have written their new book How To Stay Christian in Seminary (Crossway, 2014). David and Jonathan both work for Desiring God Ministries; John Piper wrote the book’s foreword. Jonathan is a graduate of The College at Southeastern; he was a student in some of my earliest classes. Leah and I became close friends with Jonathan and his fiancé, Melissa; after they married, they joined First Baptist Church of Durham before moving to Minneapolis for seminary.

The idea for How to Stay Christian in Seminary first came a couple of years ago when David and Jonathan blogged on this topic for Desiring God. They also asked a number of folks, including yours truly and Bruce Ashford, to weigh in on the topic. (You can read the compilation of all the posts here.) I had the privilege of reading a draft of How to Stay Christian in Seminary last year and I can tell you that this is a book that every seminarian (or prospective seminarian) should “take up and read.”

What follows is an image of the Table of Contents that I shamelessly copied from my friend Andy Naselli’s website. I hope you’ll purchase a copy of this short, inexpensive, soul-stirring book and take it to heart.

 (Note: This post was first published yesterday at Between the Times. It has been edited a bit for my personal blog.)


Noteworthy Links: Early Baptists and Anabaptists

$
0
0

Anabaptists and Contemporary BaptistsMy friend Steve Weaver has written a helpful post titled “Are We Entering  Golden Age of 17th-Century Baptist Literature?” He mentions eight new or forthcoming works, including both scholarly monographs and popular reprints with semi-scholarly introductions. Publishers include Mercer University Press, Regents Park College Publications, Pickwick, Borderstone and Reformed Baptist Academic Press. Some of the works are related to Particular Baptists, while two are monographs on the General Baptist messenger/theologian Thomas Grantham. (Grantham is my all-time favorite Arminian-ish Baptist.) My own expertise is in Baptist Studies in the 18th and 20th centuries, so I’m very interested in learning from these new publications. Thanks to Steve for pointing them out.

Scot McKnight has an interesting post on Anabaptist identity as envisioned by the influential 20th-century scholar Harold Bender. McKnight interacts with Bender’s vision of Anabaptism while also referencing the thought of other scholars who demur from the Bender thesis. This is a good, short introduction to the interpretation of Anabaptism that has influenced many Baptist scholars (both conservative and moderate) who hold to an “Anabaptist-kinship” view of Baptist origins and/or an Anabaptist-friendly understanding of Baptist identity. If you are interested in reading a helpful volume written from this perspective, see the recent festschrift in honor of Paige Patterson, The Anabaptists and Contemporary Baptists (B&H Academic, 2013), edited by my friend Malcolm Yarnell.

If you are wondering about my own views about the possible relationship between some of the Anabaptists and the earliest English Baptists, I would point you to three  blog posts I’ve written for Between the Times:  “Toward a Convergent View of Baptist Origins” (part one and part two) and “Why I Don’t Freak Out about the Anabaptists.” I would also recommend the first chapter of James Leo Garrett’s Baptist Theology: A Four Century Study (Mercer University Press, 2009) and the introduction to Baptist Roots: A Reader in the Theology of a Christian People (Judson Press, 1999), edited by Curtis Freeman, James Wm. McClendon and C. Rosalee Velloso Da Silva.

 

 

Viewing all 36 articles
Browse latest View live




Latest Images